About Us

Our First Location Opened in 1972

Our First Location Opened in 1972

Arrenello's opened its first location in Glenwood, IL in 1972. Many things have changed over the years, but one thing that has remained constant is that Arrenello's customers keep coming back for the sweet stuff...sweet sauce, that is. "On a pizza," everyone asked? We knew it would be a risk, but people liked it a lot, and from then on, we were in the pizza business!

Arenello's Old Photos — Highland, IN — Arrenello's Pizza

Award Winning Stuffed Pizza

Almost two decades ago now, Arrenello's Pizza was first hailed by the Chicago Tribune, honored as a pizza joint with one of the best stuffed pies in Chicago, which was called "remarkable." Of course, with our delicious crust, plentiful cheese, and sweet-savory sauce, our customers were far from surprised.

Award Winning Stuffed Pizza

Almost two decades ago now, Arrenello's Pizza was first hailed by the Chicago Tribune, honored as a pizza joint with one of the best stuffed pies in Chicago, which was called "remarkable." Of course, with our delicious crust, plentiful cheese, and sweet-savory sauce, our customers were far from surprised.

More Than Just Pizza

We are known for our award-winning pizza. However, if you are not in the mood for pizza, dontworryaboutit! We have an extensive menu of dishes to satisfy whatever you might be craving. From delicious pasta and salads to ribs and seafood, we have something sure to please your taste. For close to 50 years, we have kept our loyal customers coming back to Arrenello's with our fast, friendly service and award-winning dishes.

So, what are you waiting for? Give us a call and order some food already!


Call us today at Glenwood location (708-758-6160), Highland, Indiana (219-924-2525), or Tinley Park, Illinois (708-532-2424).


From our family to yours, meet the managers of your favorite location

Share by: